NoteWorthy Composer Forum

Forums => General Discussion => Topic started by: user111 on 2005-07-12 05:37 PM

Title: to Simon Carroll
Post by: user111 on 2005-07-12 05:37 PM
Did you write this waltz?
http://myfilehut.com/userfiles/user222/Waltz.mid
Title: Re: to Simon Carroll
Post by: Quasimodo on 2005-07-12 07:39 PM
I have a hunch that Simon Carroll did not compose that waltz.
After listening to some of his previous attempts at composition, I would say that that is not his style.
Also, it sounds as though it were composed quite some time before Simon was probably born.
Title: Re: to Simon Carroll
Post by: user111 on 2005-07-13 06:46 AM
But it says "By Simon Carroll" in the MIDI file though. Maybe she did the arrangement?
Title: Re: to Simon Carroll
Post by: Rob den Heijer on 2005-07-13 11:05 AM
she? Carroll is the surname. And even Carroll o'Connor is a man (so was Lewis Carroll, but that does not count)
Title: Re: to Simon Carroll
Post by: Lawrie Pardy on 2005-07-13 11:47 AM
But it says "By Simon Carroll" in the MIDI file though. Maybe she did the arrangement?

Perhaps, perhaps not - one should not believe everything one sees - especially on the internet - not even this...  Or should they... Maybe... Maybe not... Hmmm... Just who is this Lawrie Pardy person?  Should he be believed? Just what does anyone know about him?

What about user111, or Rob den Heijer, or Lewis Carrol (who seems to be numerically challenged) or that Quasimodo chap - what does _he_ know - or does he just have hunches ?

And what about that url - is user111 related to user222 - they both have similar names ?

I don't know - THIRD BASE!

:)
Title: Re: to Simon Carroll
Post by: Milton on 2005-07-14 03:52 AM
Quasimodo has hunches in bunches!
Title: Re: to Simon Carroll
Post by: Milton on 2005-07-14 03:55 AM
And from listening to the MIDI file, I've a strong hunch that the waltz is either by Chopin or Liszt.  Me thinks I'll try to find it amongst my many downloaded Chopin MIDI waltz files.