NoteWorthy Composer Forum

Forums => General Discussion => Topic started by: linlin on 2007-01-27 06:53 pm

Title: Out of tune/off-key
Post by: linlin on 2007-01-27 06:53 pm
I have a piece of music which sounds terrible! I've checked all the staffs have the same key, are playing back the same sound, but a more off-key piece of music would be hard to find. Any ideas what could be causing it?

Title: Re: Out of tune/off-key
Post by: David Palmquist on 2007-01-27 07:08 pm
Check the transpositions of the staffs.  Staff properties/Instrument/Transposition.

Also, very close intervals (1/2 tone apart) sound pretty bad on my system.  Like a chainsaw.

Title: Re: Out of tune/off-key
Post by: Richard Woodroffe on 2007-01-27 08:33 pm
This is unlikely - but in addition to the things David suggested to check also check that you haven't :
1. Attempted to do a mpc pitch bend without resetting the status afterwards.
2. That you don't have, on different staves, different instruments with the same midi channel.

Can't think of other possibilities at the moment - but failing all these tests, you could send the piece to one of us to se if anything else springs to mind. (Or attach it here)
Title: Re: Out of tune/off-key
Post by: llucyy on 2007-01-28 12:21 am
If you have transposed a staff, but not changed the MIDI in StaffProperties F2 it will still playback the untransposed pitch. Does this help?
Title: Re: Out of tune/off-key
Post by: Archive on 2007-01-28 02:21 am
Since all the conventional answers have already been said, I'm going to be extremely radical. In a rare situation, your sound card could be misfunctioning.
Title: Re: Out of tune/off-key
Post by: linlin on 2007-01-28 05:51 am
Many thanks to everyone. One staff had a different transposition setting to the others - that seems to have solved the problem.

Title: Re: Out of tune/off-key
Post by: Richard Woodroffe on 2007-01-28 09:39 am
David wins   - lol
Title: Re: Out of tune/off-key
Post by: David Palmquist on 2007-01-28 07:40 pm
The problem sounded so familiar.  If we're lucky, we learn from our mistakes. 

And I've learned a heck of a lot, which means . . .
Title: Re: Out of tune/off-key
Post by: Timoteus B on 2007-02-02 04:13 pm
There might be some comfort in this as well "Don't judge those who try and fail ,judge
those who fail to try" unknown
Title: Re: Out of tune/off-key
Post by: Archive on 2007-02-02 11:11 pm
Also judge those who try to fail!